Civil Code Change In Family Name For Children Out of Wedlock

This post has been updated, including the body of the text.

The Constitutional Court has amended the Turkish civil code to no longer automatically give children of parents who are not married the maother’s last name. Let me give you some background. Until recently, the space on the identity card for father’s name was crucial for everything — school registration, getting a passport, etc. All this needed the father’s permission. Children born out of wedlock or to couples married only with religious, not civil rites, had no legal identity.  This changed on November 22, 2001, when Turkey adopted a new Civil Code that had been shaped by years of hard work by women’s rights activists. In the new Civil Code, spouses became equal partners with equal decision-making power over their children and over property acquired during marriage. The concept of “illegitimate” child was removed and custody granted to mothers of any child born out of wedlock. This meant that mothers had legal responsibility for their children and the children had a legal identity.

Changes to the Civil Code published in the Official Gazette this week eliminates the 2001 wording from “If a child’s mother and father aren’t married, the child will take the mother’s last name“, leaving the rule for assigning a last name to children born out of wedlock up in the air. If the change in name assignment goes along with a change in status, then the implications of this change would be enormous for the rights of women and children. The news article (click here, in Turkish) doesn’t examine the repercussions. The main question is whether this change in wording goes along with other changes that would place legal responsibility for the child in the father’s and takes it out of the mother’s hands. I am also curious about why this change from the widely lauded 2001 Civil Code has occurred.

I can imagine all kinds of scenarios in which a woman gives birth out of wedlock (not least of which is rape) where giving the child the father’s last name would be inappropriate and the father can not or should not be given charge of the child. Are polygamous men complaining that the offspring of their second and third wives (who in Turkey can only be “married” by religious rites, since polygamy is illegal) are not carrying their last name? Who was the pressure group for this change?

UPDATE 2: Madde 337 in the Turkish Civil Law Code specifies that if the mother and father of a child aren’t married, the mother is the legal guardian. As long as that part of the Code remains unchanged, I presume the name change won’t have any major repercussions.

Divorce in Turkey

The Turkish Statistical Association (TIK) has released 2008 divorce and marriage statistics (for the report in English, click here) Compared to the year before, marriages remained about the same, while divorces rose 5.78%. 41% of divorces happen in the first five years of marriage. The average age of marriage is 23 for women and 26 for men. In Anatolia, the average age is lower with 22 for women and 25 for men. Not surprisingly, the divorce rate is lowest in the southeast, where divorce is most socially punitive for women and they are least likely to have an alternative source of support. (see my previous post on this here) It is highest in the more affluent and better educated Aegean area.

New NATO Commander Has Rum Background

Admiral James G. Stavridis, 54, is the new American and NATO commander in Europe. He oversees all American forces under the United States European Command and serves as the supreme allied commander, Europe, NATO’s top military position. His grandfather was an ethnic Greek born and raised in Turkey — Rum, in Turkish — who immigrated to the United States in 1910. Admiral Stavridis was born in 1955 in West Palm Beach, Fla., to a military family, and he lived in Greece as a young child while his father, an officer in the Marines, was assigned to the United States Embassy in Athens. He earned an undergraduate degree from the Naval Academy and a master’s degree and doctorate from the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University. Click here for the full profile.

Mocktails At The Ladies-Only Disco

From an article by Neeha Mujeeb (click here for full story):

…Shah Inn Paradise resort in Turkey’s beach city of Antalya has opened a ladies only disco as part of its facilities. Like any other disco it opens late, at 10 in the night, and closes at 4 in the morning, complete with a dance floor and bar. Of course, the bar only serves soft drinks and mocktails as ladies dance to the latest Turkish pop hits, also provided by a female DJ.  As consumption patterns change, many are targetting the religious crowd, giving recreation, especially holidays a new meaning from ladies only beaches to single sex gyms and discos…

I looked on the web for information about  Shah (Sah) Inn Paradise Resort and found nothing in print that tells the reader that this is a resort with gender segregated activities. It is listed as being suited for those wishing an “alternative” vacation. That seems to be the code word for pious Muslim vacation. What is on the web is an advertisement video that shows this clearly, including a woman leaping into the sea wearing a top-to-toe “Islamic” bathing suit (and by the magic of film manipulation, leaping right back out). Click here.

An Imam, a Priest, a Rabbi, and a Buddhist Monk Walked Into a TV station….

A new show on Turkish television will feature a Muslim imam, a Christian priest, a Jewish rabbi and a Buddhist monk competing each week to convert at least one of ten atheist participants to their own faith. The show, “Tövbekarlar Yarisiyor,” which can be roughly translated as “Penitents Compete,” will appear on Kanal T starting in early September. (click here)

The Friends We Keep…

Since official results of Ahmadinejad’s win were announced, only 11 countries have congratulated Ahmadinejad on his ‘victory’. These countries are Tajikistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Turkey, the People’s Republic of China, Oman, Russia, Qatar and Venezuela. (click for source)

Midnight Vote in Parliament Restricts Military Courts

(Excerpt. Click here for full article.)… [L]egislation restricting the powers of military courts, a long-standing European Union demand, was passed in Parliament in a last-minute late night meeting Friday. The legislation passed at 1:30 a.m. Saturday with the participation of a small number of opposition deputies. The opposition parties remaining silent during the session through the early hours of Saturday have led to interpretations that the legislation went unnoticed by the opposition parties. Parliament Speaker Köksal Toptan said he didn’t know about the legislation while CHP leader Deniz Baykal Sunday described the move as a kind of “midnight coup.”…

[T]he civilian courts will be able to try members of the armed forces who are accused of crimes including threats to national security, constitutional violations, organizing armed groups and attempts to topple the government in peace time. It also transfers the power to civilian courts to try civilians in peace time for offenses outlined in the military penal code…

UPDATE: the opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) announced Monday that it would apply to the Constitutional Court to annul the legislation if President Gül approves the amendment, saying that the justice minister did not fully explain the issue and that the move was against Article 145 of the Constitution, which declares that the military judiciary is responsible for cases within the military. The opposition Nationalist Movement Party, or MHP, said it would back the CHP on the issue. (click here)

What’s Going On In Iran?

I recommend this in-depth analysis of events in Iran set in the context of past elections and evaluating where things might go next. It was written by three scholars, Kaveh Ehsani, Arang Keshavarzian and Norma Claire Moruzzi, and published in Middle East Report. Read it here.

“Coup Plot” As Political Football

This post has been updated three times.

Some weeks ago, Taraf newspaper printed a copy of what they said was an official “military action plan” to discredit the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) and the Gülen movement by planting weapons in their homes and misinformation through fake news stories. This document has since become an explosive political football between the ruling AKP and the military. Right after the “action plan” was published in Taraf, the AKP, assuming the document to be real, took the matter to court. Prime Minister Erdogan has spoken harshly against the army for intending to overthrow his government. On Wednesday, the General Staff Military Prosecutor’s Office announced that the document, which bears the signature of an acting colonel, was not prepared in the General Staff headquarters and ruled out legal proceedings against the colonel who allegedly prepared it. The government is planning to present new evidence regarding this document during Tuesday’s National Security Council (MGK) meeting. The MGK is an advisory council to the government that includes high-ranking military officer. 

At a recent press conference, Chief of General Staff Gen. Ilker Basbug said that the leaking of this document was part of a constant, organized attempt to tarnish the military through the media and that “the army will no longer tolerate such campaigns” and “Keep your hands off the military.”  He repeated a statement he had made in April regarding  allegations that the army was involved in other attempts to overthrow the AKP government (lumped together under the rubric Ergenekon), that the armed forces “will not harbor any of its personnel who have been engaged in anti-democratic movements.” Basbug ruled out engaging in a “witch hunt” within the army, but assured listeners that “We have no any intention of sweeping these allegations under the carpet.” (click here for news report) Today’s Zaman, a pro-government newspaper, pointed out that the army tends to protect its officers first and then edge them out (click here) and predicted that the colonel involved in the document would face early retirement or be expelled during the upcoming August meeting of the Supreme Military Council (YAS) meeting, where removals and promotions of army officers are decided.

Click here for Yigal Schleifer’s excellent discussion of this newest “coup plot” and its importance.

UPDATE:  July 1, 2009. The alleged author of the “military action plan”, Navy Colonel Dursun Cicek, has been arrested on the order of a civilian court and charged with membership in an illegal organization (Ergenekon). He is being held in a military jail in Istanbul. (click here)

 Click here for a Washington Post article about the “action plan”.

UPDATE 2: Colonel Cicek has been released for lack of evidence. UPDATE 3. The Young Civilians, a social protest group that uses humor, has nominated the judge who released Cicek for the Guiness Book of Records as the world’s fastest reader. The case against Cicek took 18 days to compile and the judge decided in two hours to release him. (click here)

istanbullightsjennywhite.jpg

Horhor, Photo by Jenny White